Advertisement



|
|
|
|
|
|
|

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
"Sin City" gives guilty warm feeling Print E-mail
Written by RYAN COX   
Friday, 06 May 2005
It's been almost four days now since I saw "Sin City," and I honestly can't quite pin down how I feel about it. I enjoyed watching it, against my better judgment, but at the same time, it's not a movie I feel exactly comfortable recommending. It's without a doubt the most exuberantly cruel and nihilistic film to grace the suburban multiplex in years, particularly from the Hollywood machine.

It's an unrivaled vision of hell filled with the most unbelievable amounts of reckless violence maybe not seen in a "mainstream" film since the notoriously ugly "Caligula," and yet… And yet, I have nothing.

"Sin City"
Entertainment
Art

Directed by Robert Rodriguez, Frank Miller
Written by Frank Miller
Starring Mickey Rourke, Bruce Willis, Clive Owen, Jessica Alba, Nick Stahl
It's extremely rare that a piece of work so extreme as "Sin City" fails to elicit an equally strong reaction from myself (anyone who's known me for 5 minutes can attest to this), but it's usually because I hate those works. I have waged a one-man campaign against Quentin Tarantino, for example, for roughly 10 years now, based almost solely on my feeling that "Pulp Fiction" is one of the most grotesquely perverse films I've ever seen (It just so happens Tarantino also directed a segment in "Sin City," though I'm not sure which one); "Pulp Fiction" is a film that, in my opinion, revels in cruelty and the basest human emotions and motivations. I hate everything it stands for, and even though "Sin City" has "Pulp Fiction" trounced in this area, I honestly didn't hate it. I found it enthralling. Exciting. Funny, even. And it kind of makes me hate myself.

Sin City doesn't feature much of a plot to speak of. It consists of three loosely linked short films, featuring some overlapping characters that all live in Basin City ("Sin City," get it?). It's the darkest worldview imaginable, where no one is innocent and it's kill or be killed. Period. Priests, Senators, cops, they're all pedophiles, cannibals and rapists, and it's about as subtle as a knife in the eye. (Or the crotch, as "Sin City" would have it. Castration is a favorite method of execution in the film, and it occurs no less than three times: once by gun, once by ax, and once by, yes, bare hands.)

The aesthetic value of the film was quite impressive, but I also feel like everyone has seen the trailers, and maybe that's all you need to see. It's entirely computer-generated, right down to the colors of the actors' eyes. It's a fascinating gimmick and the patches of color in the gray tapestry (a ruby red dress here, some green, glowing eyes there) are used sparingly and effectively. But ultimately, special effects alone won't keep my interest. The characters are all interesting, fully fleshed-out people, and the actors are stunning (Mickey Rourke, especially). The stories are lacking, slightly, and drag on a bit too long for as thin as they actually are. If about 30 minutes had been shaved off the total 126-minute running time, I think it would have been much tidier and interesting in that respect.

Ultimately, I think "Sin City" is about a person's taking what they consider to be the moral high ground in a situation where it's irrelevant. No matter what you do, you're screwed, and by doing the "right" thing, you're consciously choosing to take that avenue for yourself and yourself only, because ultimately it won't matter. Not a horribly inspiring message, to be sure, but to think about sitting through all of that carnage and hopelessness for no reason whatsoever is too depressing to think about. For a movie that so flagrantly, and almost hatefully, dismisses any notions of PC righteousness there has to be a redeeming value somewhere. Especially since I enjoyed it so much.

Comments

Write Comment
Name:Guest
Title:
Comment:



Code:* Code

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

< Previous   Next >
Other Recent Articles by RYAN COX:
"9 Songs" an enigma
Preparing for your class reunion
"Mysterious Skin" aims to move you
"High Tension" lives up to its name
"Fever Pitch" a catch for Farrellys

Polls
I would love to see Lumino feature