Advertisement



|
|
|
|
|
|
|

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Muse Live Leaves Me Conflicted Print E-mail
Written by BARMEY UNG / Photos by BARRY BRECHEISEN   
Thursday, 18 March 2010
While fellow British acts like Coldplay, Radiohead and Oasis have found great success here in the US, Muse has been trying over a decade to make it big here in the States. Now with their fifth studio album The Resistance, maybe the trio from Devon, England has finally hit their stride as they headline big arenas in America.

Muse and Silversun Pickup


United Center
Chicago, IL
March 12, 2010

Muse was advertised as one of the best live shows by the promoters of the event at Chicago’s United Center this past Friday night. I’m definitely a fan, yet I’ve also heard a lot of mixed things about them. Walking in, the sold out crowd got me excited, but I remember what one of my friends who saw them at a festival in Istanbul describing them as “arrogant” (as if they were playing inside a glass cage and you weren’t allowed to look at them). I’m sure the band has come a long way since then her seeing them eight years ago, however I felt remnants of their past still remain.

There were perhaps a total of five words that were said to the audience from front man, Matthew Bellamy…something along the lines of, “Thank you Chicago,” screamed into the microphone beyond the point of understanding. It felt awkward in the band’s huddle moments between songs and it was as if they were deciding right there and then what song to play next. However the light show compensated for their impersonal presence, but that’s hardly a substitute. They do have to fill up that budget of $50 per ticket though. And yes, the light show was VERY impressive with strobe light warnings posted all along the outer halls. Muse appeared on three ascending and descending rotating pillars with projected live images of the band and the crowd along with few images of Middle Eastern conflicts.

While listening to them for that hour and a half, I realized there was only so much yelling and angst I was really willing to take. I wasn’t impressed or convinced when Bellamy ran to his knees playing guitar in a cliché rock star way, or when he spun around playing his guitar lifting it up and down at the same time, or when he decided to sing laying and rolling around on the floor, or when he or when he played it behind his head. Those types of things don’t impress me these days but the crowd seemed to respond by eating up ever last bit.

There were small moments where singer Bellamy sang softly and intimately with a grand piano ornamented with coordinated lights from the piano’s soundboard reflected on a open clear top. It’s too bad that it was lost and ineffective in the vast and caverness United Center. But it was a rock concert, it was meant to be loud, almost obnoxiously loud. Not a concert for those who enjoy subtlety and sensitivity, and not a band for those who enjoy such things of that nature either. Regardless of all this, Muse has perhaps finally found a US following where they’re able to do anything they want, and don’t get me wrong they are a good solid band. For me, it’s more easily digested in small doses. I’m still a fan especially in my depressed and lonely moments, but their show simply left me cold and lifeless.

Silversun Pickups who opened the show earlier in the evening, took the night for me. Their awkward sounding yet surprisingly compelling lead singer, Brian Aubert, caught my attention in a shy modest way perhaps knowing that they were performing in the shadow of Muse. The stage and sound was set up for Muse, and the result was something muddy and barely audible where everything blending together. Also, the lights were just not on point as oppose to the carefully orchestrated Muse production. However, this is typical of openers, but I’m sure Silversun Pickups will be out of that phase soon enough. They are a quirky group with a surprisingly growing following. Most of the people I know have heard of them much more than they’ve heard of Muse actually. But as I have said, that has been Muse’s challenge for sometime here. I’m looking forward to seeing much more of this LA alt rock group in the near future and hopefully in a much more intimate setting.

Comments
Your Opinion
Written by Guest on 2010-03-19 08:29:49
So, in a time when most bands spend what feels like half the concert talking instead of playing music, you decide MUSE is impersonal and arrogant for letting the music do their talking? 
 
Not only are these guys very down to earth and personable (check out their Twitter posts/pics), they are musically leaps and bounds ahead of just about every other live band. 
 
Your writing is actually very good, but your opinion seems geared more toward trying to just be different from every other critic who has been blown away by their live performance. 
 
Going in with the mind set that you may not like them and then looking for things from a biased perspective doesn't make for a very good objective review. 
 
To each their own though.
Strange Thoughts.
Written by Guest on 2010-03-19 09:06:11
Matt has always said he is shy on stage and finds it difficult to speak to the crowd. Why is that a bad thing? Letting the music do the talking instead. 
 
Muse are fantastic at what they do, keeping the pointless things out of the way and putting on a great musical show. 
 
You don't pay to hear someone chat in between songs, about what they have been doing or what the next song is about, you go to see music performed live. 
 
I for one welcome the fact the band do not feel the need to chat to the crowd and substitute that time for songs. They have more time for songs, showmanship and extravagance, exactly what a live gig should be about. 
 
Muse have been overblown, loud and exuberant for years, while not throwing in pointless chatter. That's Muse for you.
Don't patronize me
Written by Guest on 2010-03-19 09:18:39
You say you're a fan...but you sure don't sound like one. A 'fan' loves the MUSIC - and doesn't want a band to pretend they give a crap about their local sports team, or the weather. They speak through the words of their songs. And again, the way you tired of their songs....tell me again, you're no fan.
Review or Personal Opinion?
Written by Guest on 2010-03-21 08:03:23
" I wasn’t impressed or convinced when Bellamy ran to his knees playing guitar in a cliché rock star way, or when he spun around playing his guitar lifting it up and down at the same time, or when he decided to sing laying and rolling around on the floor, or when he or when he played it behind his head. Those types of things don’t impress me these days but the crowd seemed to respond by eating up ever last bit. " 
 
So what could Matt Bellamy do that would impress you? Headbang while playing the guitar like any other rock guitarist out there? Or talk about the weather during the concert?  
 
Mr. Ung, you're writing is good but it seems as though throughout the whole "review" you were looking to write negative things about the band. Hmm
Contrary
Written by Guest on 2010-03-22 16:13:05
I can only second the comments already posted in response to your review. You appear to have adopted a contrary perspective of the entire event, simply because you: 
a) Can. 
b) Secretly don't like Muse that much. 
c) Have a very preconceived notion of how rock stars should and should not behave on stage. 
 
Now, I can't fault you for any of the above. You are entitled to say whatever you like; freedom of speech is a wonderful thing. But please, when you post a review whose central premise and prognosis contradicts that of (virtually) the rest of the review universe you have to expect to get flamed.  
 
The absolute bottom line is very simple. Muse are one of the best live acts currently in existence, whether you appreciate them or not. The fact that they appear impersonal is quite frankly irrelevant when you take into account the fact that they CAN actually deliver on stage. What's more, while they don't communicate a great deal with the audience, their music does. Virtually every live performance is subtlety different - the personal touch is there to be heard in every note. 
 
Muse have no time or reason to chat with or at you. They are musicians, not politicians; in spite of what some of the lyrics may suggest!
Thanks for the comments
Written by admin on 2010-03-28 18:40:34
Hey guys it's true many bands allow the music to speak for it's self. Muse is one of those bands for sure. Plus in a arena it's not the most intimate setting. Glad you guys read the review and took the time to make your thoughts known. Keep them coming we always like to hear what you have to say. Stay tune for the Coachella review, when as you know, Muse will be on the bill. We'll have a different writer and I'm sure another take on it all! Plus more photos by me!
In my defense
Written by Guest on 2010-04-04 13:03:24
I appreciate all the feedback and the fact the you guys are reading my review. I'm sorry that many of you don't agree.  
 
I didn't mean to put so much emphasis on "talking to the audience." There was just something very cold and uncomfortable about their presence. I apologize if I could not convey that in a convincing way for some of you.  
 
I can see Muse has very passionate and devoted fans. Outside of that, hopefully, this article will open you up to the potential to perceive their concerts, or other concerts in a different light. 
 
Thanks again for the feedback! 
 
-Barmey

Write Comment
Name:Guest
Title:
Comment:



Code:* Code

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!

< Previous   Next >
Other Recent Articles by BARMEY UNG / Photos by BARRY BRECHEISEN:
No Tell Motel Shows Us the Art of the Tease
Gettin’ Down with JC Brooks and the Uptown Sound
Two Guys, a Girl and Some Guitars
Local Bands Raise Awareness for Abused Women Injustices
Rise Against Comes Home to Celebrate 10 Years

Polls
I would love to see Lumino feature